Popular Toys
Not sure what toys to buy for Nathaniel’s Toy Shop? Consider buying toys from the list below so we can bless kids with the most popular toys.
Save a trip to the store and purchase popular toys from our Amazon Wish List, 2025 Amazon Wish List.
Teens
- Art and Craft Sets
- Create your own keychains
- Rock painting kit
- Bracelet/Charm kit
- Table Games/Board Games
- Sports Equipment (basketballs, baseballs/gloves, footballs, soccer balls, fishing tackle)
- AirPods/Earbuds/Head Phones
- Perfume/Cologne Sets
- Bath Sets (lotion, body wash)
- Jewelry/Watches
- Bath Bomb Sets
- Hair Chalk Salon
- Headband making kit
- Make-Up and Nail Polish Sets
- Projector Machine/Bluetooth
- Paint Moon/Lamp Kit
- Drone
- Helicopter
- Fidget Spinners
Boys’ Toys
- LEGO Sets
- Hot Wheels Playsets/Racetracks (not cars, we have plenty!)
- Sports Equipment (basketballs, baseballs/gloves, footballs, soccer balls, golf sets, fishing rods/reels, outdoor games)
- Nerf toys
- Skateboards/bicycles/ride-on vehicles
- Remote Control vehicles (cars, trucks, drones, helicopters)
- Action Figures
- Dinosaurs
- Paw Patrol or Bluey toys
- Minecraft Related toys
Girls’ Toys
- House Play toys (kitchen, cleaning, play food, baby doll stroller)
- Blume/LOL Surprise/Baby Alive/Kindi Kids Dolls/Toys
- CoComelon toys
- Barbie Doll Sets
- Trolls Toys
- Make-Up/Nail Polish sets (age appropriate)
- Squishmallows
- Imaginary Play Sets (Playmobil, Fisher Price, Farm Sets, Animals)
- Peppa Pig Toys
Boys & Girls
- Arts & Crafts
- Star Wars/Harry Potter toys
- Disney Toys
- Marvel Toys/Items
- DC Comics
- Superhero collection
- Board Games/Puzzles
- Sensory Toys (slime, fidget toys, clay, poppits, balls, etc.)
- Fire HD 8 Tablet for Kids
- Ear Buds & Headphones
- Play-Doh Sets
- STEM/Science/DIY activity sets
- Grow your own Plant Kit
- Space adventures STEM kit
- Learning Toys (Leap Frog, Fisher Price)
- toddler musical toy sets
- Vtech Jamz Guitar
- Vtech Rock/Bop Music Player
- Beginner’s Guitar
- Electronic Drum Set
- Color Wooden Magnet Set
